Although this merry band spends the evening wailing out a string of World War II-era pop tunes that you'd swear were penned by Johnny Mercer and Hoagy Carmichael, in fact the entire score for this 1974 musical was written by Richard and Robert Sherman. In this, their only Broadway outing, the brothers Sherman (best known as the composers for such Disney films as The Jungle Book and Mary Poppins) succeeded uncannily -- sometimes to the verge of theft -- in evoking the 1940s big-band sound. There's not a tune in Over Here! you've ever heard before, but you'll think you know them all.
The show's plot is so simplistic it might have been written on the back of a Bazooka bubblegum wrapper. Except for one brief musical interlude about 1940s racial prejudice (movingly performed by Chris White), nothing is to be taken very seriously in this chronicle about a cross-country train trip on which two female band singers are looking for a third voice to fill out their trio, a hapless German spy is snooping for secrets and a hormone-happy GI is trying to score with his girl. Although the show is a harmless paean to patriotism (I was especially charmed by the youthful red-white-and-blue-spangled baton twirler), director/choreographer Janet Ehrlich has wisely avoided the pitfall of trying to lard her production with post-September 11 "significance." She's much savvier to keep it moving, keep it frenetic and -- like a real runaway train -- allow the sheer momentum to drive the action forward.
Over Here! owes its existence to toe-tapping Ruby Keeler. Back in 1971, Keeler's triumphant return to Broadway (after a 42-year absence) in No, No, Nanette opened the floodgates for a spate of musical revivals starring aging movie stars (Alice Faye in Good News, Debbie Reynolds in Irene). Thus was born Over Here! But unlike those revivals, this show was brand-new and tailor-made for the aging talents of America's wartime sweethearts, the Andrews Sisters. (Or what was left of them; LaVerne, the eldest of the three, had died in 1967.)
As Pauline and Paulette DePaul, who are setting off to entertain the troops, Maxene and Patty Andrews essentially portrayed themselves. Alas, that became the show's Achilles heel, for whereas any retirement-age actress (June Allyson, Evelyn Keyes) could take to the road in No, No, Nanette, no star wanted to suffer the indignity of merely replacing the Andrews Sisters. So when they left the show, it promptly died. There was no national tour, and the show is rarely performed in summer stock. (Curiously enough, the musical did play St. Louis. In July 1974, Over Here! suspended its Broadway run long enough to spend one week at the Muny Opera. Hard to believe now, but the Muny used to do creative things like that.)
Over Here! is no longer dependent on the presence of the Andrews Sisters. But as this exuberant amateur-theater production proclaims, it's still serendipitous to cast siblings in the two leads. Real-life sisters Linda Walsh Ryan and Sheila Jarasek seem to be having a ball performing together, yet they don't allow the family reunion to intrude on their chief responsibility, which is to dominate the proceedings. Ryan, in particular, is a knockout talent.
Anyone looking for a rousing evening of mindless good fun should look into this big-band musical. But don't tarry too long. I have a gut feeling that -- word of mouth being what it is -- by next weekend Over Here! will be the scarcest ticket in town.