Developed by a group of Jesuits in New York City in the early 1970s, the Nativity model was designed to propel underprivileged children into prep schools. Good for the families, and also for the schools, which face a perennial paucity of academically qualified minority applicants. At last count 64 schools across the nation have adopted the Nativity model, including 6 in St. Louis. While many inner-city high schools contend with dropout rates of about 50 percent, nearly 90 percent of Nativity students graduate, according to the nonprofit agency NativityMiguel Network. Of those students, 75 percent go on to college.
Such successes help raise money for the schools, which rely on donations from individuals, religious orders and corporate sponsors to offset modest tuition fees and ample scholarships.
In many ways St. Cecilia's was a perfect candidate for Nativity. Over the past four decades, the Archdiocese of St. Louis has closed 52 parochial schools owing to shrinking enrollment, and since the 1950s St. Cecilia's class rolls had dwindled from 500 or so to about 130 in 2003. For principal Jim Ford, the Nativity model promised not only to stave off closure but also to net St. Cecilia about $450,000 a year. "I visited three other Nativity schools in other cities, and they were just dynamite," Ford recalls. "They were working with kids similar to ours, who have a low economic background. I thought: 'This could be us!'"
St. Cecilia's Nativity school debuted in 2004 as one of the first to be "embedded" within a larger school. (St. Cecilia offers preschool through eighth grade.) While 90 percent of Nativity students nationwide qualify for National School Lunch Program subsidies an indication that they live at or below poverty level only 75 percent at St. Cecilia qualify.
After only one year, the school's scores on the benchmark Iowa Test of Basic Skills rose about 10 percentile points overall and enrollment climbed to about 160.
But the mood is anything but positive on the chilly January evening when about twenty St. Cecilia parents gather in the basement of a neighborhood bank for an informal meeting. "The vision we started with was not what we got," one complains. "'Jim Ford's Folly' is the best way to describe it."
Most of those present have at least one child in the middle school, whose total enrollment is 65. They voice concerns about safety: A man allegedly exposed himself to a girl as she left school; in another incident a man had spoken with a kindergartener during two recesses before a teacher noticed. There are other gripes as well: that reports had been sent home with kids for small infractions (an untucked shirt, for instance); students caught chewing gum are fined $2. An English teacher is said to have sent home a syllabus riddled with grammatical errors; a class discussion about HIV transmission veered into talk about sexual positions. A teacher purportedly called a little girl a "slut" and told students she was smarter than their parents because she had a college degree.
Parents say they've brought their concerns to the school and the archdiocese, to no avail.
Elicia Stoll, who'd intended to home-school her kids but enrolled them at St. Cecilia in 2005 because she was so impressed with the Nativity program, withdrew her son last fall seven weeks into his seventh-grade year after a series of run-ins with administrators.
"[The teacher] told him his bad behavior was a result of our bad parenting," says Stoll, adding that when she informed Ford of the exchange, "he just said she would never say that to a student. I realized I wasn't going to get anywhere."
Stoll's son, who'd begun talking about harming himself, was back to normal a few weeks after she enrolled him at a different school, she reports. She intends to transfer her daughter before next year, when she's slated to enter St. Cecilia's Nativity program.
"I love the parish, but I'm not sending my daughter back next year," Stoll says.
She isn't alone. Lisa Garcia has two kids enrolled in the Nativity program and another in fifth grade at St. Cecilia but not for long. Garcia says she knows teachers and schools aren't infallible. "But," she asks, "how many times do they have to repeat a mistake before something is done about it?"
Garcia believes the Nativity model isn't a good fit for the families of St. Cecilia. "This would be a good program for children with problem families," she argues. "But we're not those kind of people. This is not for a school where parents are involved."
Ford concedes that the school has suffered from some lapses in communication, but says he has always had what he calls a "classic open-door policy."
The unhappy parents say their frustrations were exacerbated by a December meeting with administrators during which they felt they were condescended to by Ford and St. Cecilia pastor Richard Tillman. They were allowed only three minutes apiece to speak and were forbidden to refer to specific events or people, they say.
"[Tillman] sat, smirked, and checked his watch repeatedly while parents cried and said that their children could not return to school unless things changed," one of the parents, Mary Cole, wrote to the archdiocese.
The response from Denny Bram, director of elementary schools at the archdiocese's Catholic Education Office: "I encourage you to continue to work with the school."
"That was where the problem was in the first place," Cole protests. "They gave me the run-around. It's like a Ping-Pong game."
Ford recognizes that "if a parent thinks a teacher did something wrong, they want to see action." But, he says, confidentiality requirements forbid him from discussing details with parents or with the media.
At any rate, not everyone came away from the meeting unhappy. "We love the Nativity model," says Luz Llanos, who emigrated from Colombia five years ago with her husband and two children. "Sometimes we don't have the resources to take our children to arts classes or music classes."
Llanos says it was the parents who were disrespectful at the December meeting. "They were yelling at the principal and one person cursed," she says.
Acknowledges Ford: "We make mistakes and we try to deal with that. If parents feel that we have put them down, I apologize. But some of them just want a different concept."
That suggestion offends Jim Cummings, a retired businessman who has paid for the eleven children of his two foster sons to attend St. Cecilia. "Many [of us] have worked long and hard to keep this school going," Cummings contends. "We kind of have a vested interest in the thing."
For years Cummings had donated a $500 subsidy on top of the monthly tuition fee of $216.66 per family. But he cut off the extra money last fall, he says, after Ford "banned" him from having contact with teachers.
Nanette Windisch, whose daughter is enrolled in St. Cecilia's Nativity school, worries that if the bickering escalates, the school will lose its funding. "There have been mistakes on both the parents' end and the school's end," she says. "But there are a lot of good things going on at the school. Parents forget that this school was on the chopping block to close."
Contact the author firstname.lastname@example.org