Jay Nixon Vetoes Bill To Block Federal Firearm Laws, Signs Another Expanding Gun Rights


Rep. Casey Guernsey, supporter of HB 436. - VIA FACEBOOK
  • via Facebook
  • Rep. Casey Guernsey, supporter of HB 436.

Missouri Governor Jay Nixon is not a fan of the "most hardcore Second Amendment bill" in the country, but he is a fan of gun rights!

Nixon, a Democrat, today vetoed one of the most high-profile Republican bills at the legislature this session -- a proposal to ban the enforcement of federal gun laws, which would likely lead to an expensive legal battle with the U.S. Attorney General. But included his announcement today was news that he is approving another firearms bill aimed at expanding the rights of gun owners in the state.

Nixon emphasizes that he is a gun owner and hunter who very much supports the Second Amendment.

See also: - Dems Slam Bill to Loosen Weapon Storage Restrictions for State Employees' Cars - Does Missouri Have "Most Extreme" States' Rights Push? Gun Law Ban Scrutinized - Missouri's Gun Bills: Concealed-Carry Permits Easier to Get, Record-Keeping Banned

The bill he signed into law today is House Bill 533, a proposal that, among several expanded gun rights, allows a state employee to keep a firearm in his or her vehicle while on state property. The bill also allows a fire chief to carry a concealed firearm and "expresses the General Assembly's support of responsible gun ownership."


"As a gun owner and hunter, I support the Second Amendment rights of Missourians and oppose efforts to undermine them," Nixon says in a statement. "That is why, as Governor, I have enacted legislation to expand gun rights, including bills to strengthen the Castle Doctrine and to allow more Missourians to carry concealed weapons. House Bill 533 is a sensible expansion of Missouri's already strong protections for gun owners."

During debate on HB 533, some Democrats criticized the proposal as an irresponsible loosening of gun storage laws.

The bill includes this symbolic language:

The general assembly of the state of Missouri strongly promotes responsible gun ownership, including parental supervision of minors in the proper use, storage, and ownership of all firearms, the prompt reporting of stolen firearms, and the proper enforcement of all state gun laws. The general assembly of the state of Missouri hereby condemns any unlawful transfer of firearms and the use of any firearm in any criminal or unlawful activity.

Meanwhile, House Bill 436, the so-called Second Amendment Preservation, is not a responsible expansion of gun rights in Missouri, Nixon says.

The bill would have directly violated the United States Constitution by nullifying federal gun policy and actually criminalizing the enforcement of certain laws. The bill also would have infringed upon the First Amendment, he says.

In addition to the aim of blocking federal gun control, the legislation also sought to curb the publishing of gun owners' names (after a New York newspaper made headlines when it published a database of local handgun permit holders).

"Under well-established legal precedent, state legislation such as House Bill 436 that seeks to resurrect the pre-Civil War concept of nullification would violate the Supremacy Clause," the governor's office says. "The bill also would have made it a crime for anyone to publish the name or other information of someone who owns a firearm."

Nixon says the included broad ban on this kind of speech could lead to bizarre acts of criminality on the part of journalists: "In fact, under this bill, newspaper editors around the state that annually publish photos of proud young Missourians who harvest their first turkey or deer could be charged with a crime."

Governor Jay Nixon, right. - VIA
  • via
  • Governor Jay Nixon, right.

The legislation has gotten a fair amount of attention as one of the "most extreme" states' right initiatives in the country.

Republican lawmakers could try and override Nixon's veto on this.

The governor's press announcement includes a long list of Nixon's record on gun rights, noting that he signed legislation lowering the right-to-carry age for active duty military in Missouri. He also signed into law a "Castle Doctrine" bill that allows small business owners and farmers to use deadly force on intruders on property they own or lease.

In case there was any doubt, the governor's office even outlines his work as attorney general related to gun rights:

In 2008, then-Attorney General Nixon was among the first attorneys general in the nation to file a brief with the U.S. Supreme Court urging it to strike down the Washington, DC gun ban and adopt the position that the Second Amendment guarantees an individual right to keep and bear arms. He also defended Missouri's conceal carry law before the Missouri Supreme Court and obtained reciprocity agreements from other states to recognize Missouri's conceal carry permits, making Missouri's endorsement the most widely recognized in the nation.

Here's a copy of House Bill 533 and House Bill 436, along with Nixon's full veto statement.

HB 533

HB 436

HB 436 Veto

Send feedback and tips to the author. Follow Sam Levin on Twitter at @SamTLevin.

Support Local Journalism.
Join the Riverfront Times Press Club

Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state. Our readers helped us continue this coverage in 2020, and we are so grateful for the support.

Help us keep this coverage going in 2021. Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing membership pledge, your support goes to local-based reporting from our small but mighty team.

Join the Riverfront Times Club for as little as $5 a month.