Despite Blistering Vatican Censure, US Nuns Flying High After Conference in STL


Buoyed by public support
  • Buoyed by public support

American nuns met in St. Louis last week and decided to tell the Vatican to cut the nunsense--albeit in gentler, more sisterly terms.

After a weekend of prayer and reflection here in Sainta Louisia, the Leadership Conference of Women Religious, which represents about 80 percent of American nunhood, announced that it would not submit to a Vatican-mandated takeover, but would instead seek continued dialogue with Rome over charges that the group's leadership is "radical feminist".

In April, the Vatican issued an 8-page doctrine that was sharply critical of the leadership of LCWR for spending too much time on issues like poverty and social justice, and not enough time condemning homosexuality and abortion, the great mainstays of the Roman Catholic Church.

The Holy See has announced that it will assign a team of bishops to take over the LCWR and realign it with the hard and fast values of the church--a mandate LWCR rejected on Friday, in favor of dialogue with a panel of archbishops.

These "radical feminunzies" have exposed a rift between American Catholics regarding the mission and structure of the Church. St Louis, with its diverse population of 650,000 Catholics, was the perfect staging ground.

Feminunzies?: Franciscan Sister Pat Farrell, center, president of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious, president-elect Franciscan Sister Florence Deacon, left, and Dominican Sister Mary Hughes, right, past president of the organization. - VIA CNS / SID HASTINGS
  • Via CNS / Sid Hastings
  • Feminunzies?: Franciscan Sister Pat Farrell, center, president of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious, president-elect Franciscan Sister Florence Deacon, left, and Dominican Sister Mary Hughes, right, past president of the organization.

Rose Mary Dowling, president of the Franciscan Sisters of Mary, told St. Louis on the Air that she was pleased with the outcome of the conference and looked forward to further dialogue with the bishops who have censured them.

"A long time ago I was taught that every one of us has a piece of the truth," she said. "Is there any way that we can bring those pieces together for the betterment of society, for the church and for the world at this point in history."

The Archdiocese of St Louis, released a statement emphasizing that he would be speaking at the conference, basically just because he had to:

Recently, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith has brought to light some very difficult and sensitive issues involving some of the programming and content that is featured at the LCWR assemblies. Archbishop Carlson is aware of this controversy and played no role in the planning of this assembly, the selection of speakers, or its honorees.

"My presence only indicates my love for the Church, the doctrinal concern for the Holy See -- which I support -- my memory of the wonderful religious who helped me in my earliest days as a child, my gratitude for the extraordinary work of Sisters today, especially in the Archdiocese of St. Louis, and my hope for resolution to the challenges that exist at this time within the community of faith," said Archbishop Carlson.

His predecessor, Cardinal Raymond Burke, has been more blunt about what he thinks of the ladies of LCWR. "If it can't be reformed, then it doesn't have a right to continue," Burke told EWTN, a Catholic television network, last week. "How in the world can these consecrated religious who have professed to follow Christ more closely ... be opposed to what the Vicar of Christ is asking? This is a contradiction."

Jennifer Reyes Lay, program coordinator for the St. Louis-based Catholic Action Network, told Daily RFT that her organization will continue to support LCWR throughout their conversations with the bishops.

"There are a number of Catholics throughout St. Louis who are concerned about what's happening," she said. "I think there's a good population here supporting the sisters and wanting to see more progressive action from the church... people want to maintain their Catholic identity in a way that's healthy and fulfilling for them."

Demographics show that with 70 million members, the Roman Catholic Church is still the largest religious denomination in the U.S. But many are fond of saying that the second largest religious denomination belongs to the 26 million people who identify as lapsed or "fallen-away" Catholics.

When asked about the Catholic Church losing the hearts and minds of modern Catholics, Fran Raia of the Sisters of the Most Precious Blood in O'Fallon told STL Public Radio that she sees it and it pains her.

"We're failing in ways to give hope to people, especially our young people," Raia said. "We understand the pain of Catholics who have turned away and we want to reach out to them, to you, and lament that this is happening. And that the structures are such that they cannot tolerate them [lapsed Catholics] anymore." Reyes-Lay said we might see the growth of alternative parishes--like St. Therese of Divine Peace where women are ordained as priests and leaders of the congregation--as people look outside an increasingly inflexible structure.

About 300 well-wishers joined Reyes-Lay and the Catholic Action Network near the grounds of the Arch to pray and show support for LCWR. CAN also held a vigil outside the Cathedral Bascilica in Central West End, where the Archdiocese is headquartered. Reyes-Lay said the Archdiocese did not respond to her invitation to join the vigil, but she was heartened that the Cathedral staff did not kick them off the property either.

LCWR nun or Lady Gaga? You decide.
  • LCWR nun or Lady Gaga? You decide.

Elsewhere, other St. Louis Catholics have been less enthusiastic. The prolific blogger "thetimman", a self-described St. Louis-area male who supports "Traditional Mass and Sacraments", had this to say on his blog SaintLouisCatholic about LWCR and the support they have received:

And as long as the LCWR orders are solidly in the camp of the left wing of the political world, ready to undermine the interests of the Church by giving political cover to those who hate Her, they will receive full protection from the media and their fellow travelers in the Church. They will have full and free reign to continue to agitate for socialism politically, and to embrace whatever heresy floats their collective boat. They will be cheered as they continue to support government programs that violate the Natural Law, kill the most innocent, and undermine the very fabric of society. They can just go on wearing their comfortable shoes, linking arms in front of nuclear power plants, supporting sodomitical "unions", and living in their tidy apartments.

Feminunzies: baby-killers in Crocs, who have Bacchus pro-sodomy gatherings outside nuclear power plants... and really clean apartments. Sounds like a hot new reality show, right?

Support Local Journalism.
Join the Riverfront Times Press Club

Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state. Our readers helped us continue this coverage in 2020, and we are so grateful for the support.

Help us keep this coverage going in 2021. Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing membership pledge, your support goes to local-based reporting from our small but mighty team.

Join the Riverfront Times Club for as little as $5 a month.