Owners of U.S. Fidelis Indicted for Fraud, Stealing, Unlawful Merchandising


Yes, an angel's halo really did adorn the US Fidelis logo. - CONSUMERIST.COM
  • consumerist.com
  • Yes, an angel's halo really did adorn the US Fidelis logo.
I admit it. Given all the allegations regarding bad business practices made against brothers Darain and Cory Atkinson over the past couple years, I thought they'd already been criminally indicted.

Apparently not. Well, not until last week, anyway.

In an indictment issued last Wednesday -- and made public yesterday -- the Atkinsons are charged with unlawful merchandising practices, stealing and insurance fraud while operating their now-bankrupt company, U.S. Fidelis.

Just two years ago, the Wentzville-based business was an industry leader in the shady world of extended auto warranty retailers. The company had 1,100 employees and generated millions in revenue. Then came the report from the Better Business Bureau in April 2009 that it had received more than 33,000 inquiries and more than 1,100 complaints against U.S. Fidelis in the previous 36 months.

Just like that, as quickly as as it had mushroomed, U.S. Fidelis collapsed, and the Atkinson brothers were forced to liquefy their assets, selling off their exotic cars and monstrous mansions, to satisfy creditors.

And now, adding insult to injury, comes the indictment that's being personally handled by the state's top prosecutor, Attorney General Chris Koster. The indictment specifically alleges that the Atkinsons:

  • kept refunds that were due consumers
  • charged fees in excess of the amount stated in the contract
  • told consumers they would get a pro rata refund if they canceled the contract, while intending to keep a portion of any refund.

The Atkinsons are also accused of misleading consumers into believing that:

  • U.S. Fidelis was affiliated with auto manufacturers and dealers
  • the consumer's warranty had expired or was about to expire
  • the consumer had the opportunity to extend or reinstate the manufacturer's warranty.
Darain Atkinson, a prior felon convicted in the 1980s of theft, forgery, burglary and manufacturing counterfeit Federal Reserve Notes, could get life in prison if convicted. His brother, who also has a prior felony for trespassing, could face up to fifteen years in prison if convicted.

Too bad that the government can't also prosecute the brothers for hypocrisy in marketing U.S. Fidelis as a wholesome "faith-based" company. You know, the kind that sponsors Christian-themed New Year's Eve parties.

Support Local Journalism.
Join the Riverfront Times Press Club

Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state. Our readers helped us continue this coverage in 2020, and we are so grateful for the support.

Help us keep this coverage going in 2021. Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing membership pledge, your support goes to local-based reporting from our small but mighty team.

Join the Riverfront Times Club for as little as $5 a month.