Black Sheriff Deputies Once Again Dicked Over by the Man


Troy Cardona administers a little Jeff-Co street justice in the STL. - TROYCARDONA.COM
  • Troy Cardona administers a little Jeff-Co street justice in the STL.
A Jefferson County judge yesterday drastically reduced the damages that two black St. Louis sheriff deputies won in a September trial alleging racial discrimination. Saying the $350,000 in punitive damages awarded to plaintiffs William "Pat" Hill and Jacques Hughes were "excessive and shock the conscience," Judge Troy Cardona set the new reward at just $75,000.

Here, though, is what doesn't -- in Cardona's words -- "shock the conscience." That's the fact that Cardona is a white, good ol' boy who campaigns for his elected position in an orange hot-rod he calls "Street Justice" but looks -- for all intents and purposes -- like the General Lee in the Dukes of Hazard.

Is it really any wonder, then, that someone like Cardona would step up for St. Louis Sheriff James Murphy -- a man who the jury of ten whites and two blacks recently found to have fostered a racially hostile department?

Answer: No.

Sheriff James Murphy
  • Sheriff James Murphy
The truth is that the punitive damages of $350,000 to both Hill and Hughes is peanuts compared to what they've endured over the past four years -- ever since their white colleagues hanged a noose near a holding cell full of black prisoners in the basement of the Civil Courts building. All Hill and Hughes wanted was for Murphy to acknowledge the incident and set up procedures to ensure that such insensitive horseplay didn't occur again.

It wasn't like it was the first incident of racism within the department. As brought up during the trial, whites colleagues who referred to their black coworkers as "porch monkeys" and "niggers" had largely gone undisciplined under Murphy's 21 years as sheriff.

When Murphy refused to discipline the people who hanged the noose and ignored Hill and Hughes request for a meeting, they sued. In response, Hill was demoted to the graveyard shift. Hughes, meanwhile, was fired. And, Murphy? He refused to see any wrong.

Right before the jury was to consider punitive damages for the case, Murphy took the stand. Asked whether he was sorry that the noose was hanged in the Civil Courts building, the sheriff avoided the question. Instead he answered that he was sorry that the plaintiffs took offense to the symbol.

Jerry Dobson, Hughes and Hill's attorney, told me after the trial that he thought his clients would receive less in punitive damages until Murphy made that statement.

"I think that really angered the jury," said Dobson.

In attempting to send Murphy a message, the jury upped the ante to $350,000. Is that sum really as "excessive" as Cardona says it is?

Not really. Not when you consider the risk that Hill and Hughes took in challenging the sheriff that the racist B.S. needed to stop. Not when you consider that the money doesn't include the cut to the attorney.

But, hey, these were just two lazy employees trying to make a buck off the city, right? They should be happy with what they got. Read Jacques Hughes' story, and just try to make that argument.

Riverfront Times works for you, and your support is essential.

Our small but mighty local team works tirelessly to bring you high-quality, uncensored news and cultural coverage of St. Louis and beyond.

Unlike many newspapers, ours is free – and we'd like to keep it that way, because we believe, now more than ever, everyone deserves access to accurate, independent coverage of their community.

Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing pledge, your support helps keep St. Louis' true free press free.