Florence + the Machine at the Peabody, 4/29/12: Review, Photos, Setlist


  • Kholood Eid

Florence + the Machine Peabody Opera House April 29, 2012

It's been a year since St. Louis last hosted Florence + the Machine, but things have changed in the short time that's passed. Florence Welch has been catapulted into a whole other realm of popularity, selling out the Peabody Opera House in what felt like the blink of an eye, or in the time it takes a browser to refresh for a chance at whatever seats might still be available.

Or in actuality, less than 30 minutes. The band released its second album, Ceremonials, in November, and it dominated charts across the pond and debuted at number six in the States.

The Peabody suits Ms. Welch, with its sophisticated beauty and grandeur - attributes shared with Ceremonials. The stage was set with pillars of stained glass, tall structures that resembled the inside of a giant clock and eight other musicians accompanying Welch (two backup singers, Tom Monger on the harp, bassist, Rob Ackroyd on guitarist, Chris Hayden on drums, pianist and Isabella Summers on keyboard). Despite there being so many people on stage, it never looked or felt crowded. The rest of the set often disappeared into darkness, leaving Welch standing, swaying and belting her lungs out in a spotlight reserved only for her. And of course, there was the fan positioned in front of Welch, giving a constant breeze that only enhances her look of being this ethereal creature, floating before us in a long black gown with a plunging neckline and collar.

But the frills are secondary to her stage presence. And that voice.

Florence + the Machine dove right in to "Only If For A Night," the opening track on Ceremonials and a fantastic way to take hold of an audience. Beginning only with Welch's powerfully poignant voice, in contrast to the softness of the harp and the striking piano, the song slowly builds, spilling into the chorus. Still, there was something missing on the crowd's part, or at least as far as Welch was concerned. After wrapping up the first song, she suggested we ditch our seats and stand, which we gladly obliged.

Welch then continued to fill the theatre with her chill-inducing vocals, occasionally stepping away from the mic to fiercely twirl her long, billowing cape until the fabric itself came alive, engulfing her in layers of patterns that almost gave an illusion of flames licking her body.

But it wasn't until the second half of the performance that Welch really let loose, pleasantly chatting with the audience and repeatedly thanking them for coming out to see her -- especially with Van Halen playing the Scottrade Center the same night. "We've had a lovely day. I've learned about the Cardinals," Welch told the crowd to cheers still fresh from a World Series victory and the impressive start to the current baseball season. "And you all could be seeing Van Halen, so I'm glad you came." Welch then mentioned how she slipped out to see Kool & the Gang, who opened for the classic rockers, and bought a Van Halen t-shirt before her own gig. It was certainly a busy evening in downtown St. Louis. With the two venues next to one another, one way to pass the time was by playing "Guess Which Band Those Folks Are Going To See: Van Halen or Florence + the Machine?" It wasn't a terribly challenging game.

The show's biggest flaw was that it lacked the delightfully twisted tales that the band's first album, Lungs, had to offer, such as "Girl With One Eye," or the outlandishly violent "Kiss With a First." The majority of the songs performed were from Ceremonials, with the set clocking in at almost exactly one hour long (excluding the encore). But there were no complaints heard among the crowd.

  • Kholood Eid

Most of Welch's energy came bursting out for the last two songs of the set, "Shake It Out" followed by "Dog Days Are Over," the band's breakout single from its debut album. For both songs, she glided across the stage, barefoot and twirling, much more like a flower child than the elegant and poised figure who earlier cried out to demons only she could see. For "Dog Days Are Over," almost as soon as she began the song, she abruptly stopped with a laugh.

"I actually did this on purpose," she said to the crowd, who were caught off guard by what seemed to be the evening's first slip up.

Welch then instructed the audience to sing along, and asked one more favor of them. The last favor of the evening, she promised. She leapt as high as she could, with a sort of childish fervor that proved infectious among the crowd when she requested that we all give it a try. The mark for our jumping was when she shouted "St. Louie" during the song, and the sold out crowd did not stop jumping until the song ended, the lights dimmed and the stage cleared.

The band then came back out for a two-song encore, which consisted of "Never Let Me Go," (with additional male vocals provided by the pianist and drummer Chris Hayden that blended well with back up singers' vocals during the chorus) and "No Light, No Light," before the evening ended.

Critic's Notebook:

Side note: During "Lover to Lover," as Welch gestured and stared intently into the distance, somewhere well beyond the upper balcony of the Peabody (more specifically, the "space among the clouds") the woman in front of me actually tried to follow her gaze to find the point of this focus.

Overheard: After the first song, a man from the audience loudly declared his love for Welch as the applause died down, which made her giggle.

Personal bias: As much as I enjoy Ceremonials, I prefer Lungs overall and was pretty disappointed to miss the likes of "Drumming Song" and "Kiss With a Fist." But I made up for it on the car ride home. And not to air grievances, but as lovely as the Peabody is, it's a hell of a challenge for photographers to shoot restricted to one side of the stage.

Setlist: Only If For One Night What the Water Gave Me Cosmic Love Rabbit Heart (Raise It Up) Spectrum Heartlines Leave My Body Lover to Lover Shake It Out Dog Days Are Over Encore: Never Let Me Go No Light, No Light

Support Local Journalism.
Join the Riverfront Times Press Club

Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state. Our readers helped us continue this coverage in 2020, and we are so grateful for the support.

Help us keep this coverage going in 2021. Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing membership pledge, your support goes to local-based reporting from our small but mighty team.

Join the Riverfront Times Club for as little as $5 a month.