But last Thursday, the restaurant finally opened its doors -- and drew a steady drumbeat of customers all weekend long. By late Saturday night, as well as Sunday around 6 p.m., servers were apologizing for running out of various staples.
One reason for the delay in opening is surely the complete overhaul the Czarnecs have given the space at 4900 Laclede since its days as a Greek-inflected diner. The Majestic was a neighborhood institution, a great place for a hungover brunch or a pitcher of beer -- but the look of the restaurant that's replaced it is a huge upgrade.
Exposed brick walls and hardwood floors are the backdrop to a host of stylish details, from the faux-cowhide throws on the benches to the Art Deco heads holding up shelves in the main dining room. Even the bathrooms have been given a major facelift, with striking white tiles and rosewater-scented soap.
As befitting a place where the servers' T-shirts note that "whiskey is water with soul," the whiskey list is voluminous. Just how voluminous isn't exactly clear, however, since the restaurant is still working on a final written accounting to give to patrons.
For now, you're advised to belly up to the bar and see if something catches your fancy, or perhaps just try a Manhattan. Amanda Hammond, a Niche veteran who runs the drinks program, learned to make them for her grandfather, and the servers are properly enthusiastic in suggesting them.
Unlike that roster of whiskeys, the menu itself is short and sweet. Try one of five barbecue plates -- St. Louis-cut pork ribs, beef ribs, salmon, BBQ pork steak or pulled pork -- or one of four sandwiches: a burger, a pulled pork sandwich, a shredded turkey or a vegetarian option made of zucchini, squash, tomatoes, pepper and onion.
Each plate comes with two sides, while sandwiches come with one. Choose between potato salad, slaw, baked beans or corn bread.
Turn the page for more photos of The BBQ Saloon.
But the real highlight comes in the short list of starters. The menu contains a warning about the candied bacon: "Dare you to try and eat just one."
It isn't easy. The four long strips of brown-sugar-carmelized pork are a good reminder that, even if bacon has become too trendy for its own good, it comes by its popularity honestly. This is a truly delicious rendering of an always-delicious cut of meat. Even though it made a great beginning to the meal, we found ourselves tempted also to end with it.
The housemade crackl'ns, which come in either salt-and-vinegar or barbecue, were also delightful. But it's pretty hard to top the combination of brown sugar and bacon.
The BBQ Saloon may have been a long time in coming, but now that it's here, the restaurateurs plan to be open seven days a week. Just make sure to get there before they run out. Even with no publicity, they were doing a damn good job of making that happen on their very first weekend.
Gut Check is always hungry for tips and feedback. E-mail the author at email@example.com