The 5 Best Italian Restaurants (Not Cheap) in St. Louis


       The can't-miss "Hunter's Egg" at Mad Tomato. | Jennifer Silverberg
  •        The can't-miss "Hunter's Egg" at Mad Tomato. | Jennifer Silverberg

Traditionally, St. Louisans looking for great Italian food head straight to the Hill. These days, though, the love is spread out a little bit more. There are still decades-old, classic restaurants on the Hill, but it no longer has a monopoly for that perfect first date spot, complete with pasta and good wine. Check out our current favorites -- and let us know yours in the comments.

See also: Cucina Pazzo Brings Rustic Italian to Former Duff's Location in the Central West End

       The egg raviolo at Acero. | Ian Froeb
  •        The egg raviolo at Acero. | Ian Froeb

Acero (7266 Manchester Road, Maplewood; 314-644-1790)

Jim Fiala's Acero is entirely unlike the traditional Italian restaurant. It's elegant and spare, with the menu to match. The front patio is delightful in warm weather, and your server will explain the provenance of everything, down to the Buffalo's milk cheese. The star, though, is the egg raviolo: egg yolk wrapped in delicate pasta, served on a bed of mascarpone, ricotta and Parmigiano-Reggiano.

       Giovanni's is the real deal. | Sarah Rusnak
  •        Giovanni's is the real deal. | Sarah Rusnak

Giovanni's on the Hill (5201 Shaw Avenue; 314-772-5958)

On the other side of the spectrum, Giovanni's is a Hill institution. Impeccable white tablecloths, deferential waiters, perfect Alfredo sauce, and a famous guest list to boot. Giovanni's counts multiple presidents, Oprah and even Frank Sinatra as guests over the past 40 years. Try the veal chop with black truffle sauce or the lobster risotto. It's the place for fine dining, Italian or not -- consider it the little black dress of restaurants.

       Fettuccine-Gulf Shrimp is served with fresh pasta, olives, capers, basil, chiles and tomato. | Jennifer        Silverberg
  •        Fettuccine-Gulf Shrimp is served with fresh pasta, olives, capers, basil, chiles and tomato. | Jennifer        Silverberg

Mad Tomato (8000 Carondelet, Clayton; 314-932-5733)

Chef Vito Racanelli Jr. just keeps getting better and better. First Big V's, then Onesto, and now, the great Mad Tomato. It's rustic, but still upscale -- entrees are served in cast iron skillets. There are also delicious Neapolitan-style pizzas and antipasti that shouldn't be ignored. Our favorite is the "Hunter's Egg," an egg poached in tomato broth over polenta. Or go ahead and get a whole rack of lamb, if that's what you're feeling. Either way, you'll leave full and satisfied.

       Arancini. | Ian Froeb
  •        Arancini. | Ian Froeb

Lorenzo's Trattoria (1933 Edwards Street; 314-773-2223)

Lorenzo's is another Hill go-to, but it gives you a more casual setting without downgrading the food. The osso bucco is basically a religious experience: fork-tender braised veal shank with marrow (a.k.a. the "butter of the gods") inside, complete with a marrow spoon so you can spread it on some warm bread. Just try not to fill up on those tasty breadsticks first.

       Bruschetta at I Fratellini. | Tara Mahadevan
  •        Bruschetta at I Fratellini. | Tara Mahadevan

I Fratellini (7624 Wydown Boulevard, Clayton; 314-727-7901)

Zoe Robinson Pidgeon may be busy expanding her Frenchrestaurant in Clayton, but before Bar Les Freres, there was I Fratellini. It's tiny, too, but somehow just right. Chef Ny Vongsaly's menu has classics like short ribs braised in red wine and can't-miss appetizers like Belgian endive stuffed with fresh mozzarella and then wrapped in prosciutto. Feeling frisky? Try the rabbit-spinach ravioli. Oh, and definitely save room for dessert.

Gut Check is always hungry for tips and feedback. Email the author at [email protected] or follow her on Twitter.

Support Local Journalism.
Join the Riverfront Times Press Club

Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state. Our readers helped us continue this coverage in 2020, and we are so grateful for the support.

Help us keep this coverage going in 2021. Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing membership pledge, your support goes to local-based reporting from our small but mighty team.

Join the Riverfront Times Club for as little as $5 a month.