Vote for St. Louis' Most Overrated Pizza


  • Jennifer Silverberg

We asked you to nominate St. Louis' most overrated pizza, and you responded. More specifically, many of you -- a clear majority -- named one of two very well known local operations that, as it happens, couldn't be more different from each other. One is a favorite of generations of St. Louis. One is a favorite of many among the St. Louis food media, this publication (and yours truly) included. So overwhelming was the response that we struggled to come up with more than these two nominees.

The Finalists

BlackThorn Pizza & Pub (3735 Wyoming Street; 314-776-0534)

Corey Butler: I waited till I was 21 to enjoy their burnt, mound of greasy cheese with no sauce.

Dewey's Pizza (multiple locations)

jwilkins88: I'm gonna say it...Dewey's. I've just never understood the hype.

Imo's Pizza (multiple locations)

jkingstl: Absolutely, without a doubt - Imo's I actually really like provel as an option for pizza, and I dig most other St. Louis style pizzas, but I just don't get the Imo's love - at all. Also? Why is it so damned expensive?

Editor's Note: I like this take on why Imo's is overrated because it allows for an acceptance of St. Louis-style pie, which not all of us (ahem) like in just about any form.

Peel Wood Fired Pizza (921 South Arbor Vitae, Edwardsville, Illinous; 618-659-8561)

@Shep: I'll go with Peel. Not sure why this gets raves from many. I can only think, they haven't had good pizza. Toppings aren't fresh and there's nothing much to the crust. It isn't worth a trip from STL.

Pi Pizzeria (multiple locations)

jmorgan.bills: I'll 2nd Pi. I can't stand the cornmeal crust, it tastes like someone added sand to the mix.

You also have the option to write in your own choice for the most overrated pizza. Voting concludes at noon this Friday, February 8.

Support Local Journalism.
Join the Riverfront Times Press Club

Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state. Our readers helped us continue this coverage in 2020, and we are so grateful for the support.

Help us keep this coverage going in 2021. Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing membership pledge, your support goes to local-based reporting from our small but mighty team.

Join the Riverfront Times Club for as little as $5 a month.