Pujols 5 Westport Grill vs. Ozzie's Restaurant & Sports Bar: A Baseball Icon Nacho Throwdown!


As the temperature outside reached the triple digits -- even higher if you happened to be a Cardinals outfielder -- we were sweating it out over two plates of nachos, one from a future Hall of Famer's namesake place, one from a 2002 inductee. It's Pujols 5 Westport Grill vs. Ozzie's Restaurant & Sports Bar. Play ball.

(Of course, this isn't the first time the two restaurants have tussled. Now that Ozzie's has departed Westport Plaza for Washington Avenue, the score stands Pujols 5 - 1, Ozzie's - 0.)

Click through for the contenders, the battle and the verdict.

The Contenders

First up is Pujols 5 Westport Grill. Waitresses, who sport red flowers in their hair, are constantly kept on their toes by a bar that's packed, even on a hot as Hell Tuesday.

Albert Pujols will deliver your nachos as soon as his home run clears the fence. - ORIGINAL IMAGE VIA
  • Original image via
  • Albert Pujols will deliver your nachos as soon as his home run clears the fence.
The colorful "Chipotle Chicken Nachos" call to mind a Funfetti cake: The black olives, yellow corn, green onions, jalapeños and cheddar cheese all contrast nicely against the sour cream and festive red and white tortilla chips. (The only downside to the red ones was that their dye tinged the chicken a somewhat disconcerting fuchsia.)

But the promised black beans were merely a smear, and some of the cheddar was as scorched as a fan in the bleacher seats. The fire-roasted tomato salsa was spicy and smoky -- a definite highlight -- and the chicken was so tender you could easily imagine it starring on a sandwich. Though Pujols 5 doesn't reinvent this bar-food staple, the $7.95 nachos certainly cover all the bases and were more than filling enough for two people.

By the time we reach Ozzie's Restaurant & Sports Bar a few innings later, the Cardinals have somehow managed to dig themselves in a double-digit hole. Perhaps the "Easy to Eat Nachos" there will salvage some aspect of these dismal late innings.

The nachos at Ozzie's Restaurant & Sports Bar - KRISTIE MCCLANAHAN
  • Kristie McClanahan
  • The nachos at Ozzie's Restaurant & Sports Bar
At $8.25 the appetizer seems a bit steep, especially when the menu says we'll get just eight tortilla chips. Plus, the notion of "Easy to Eat Nachos" is a bit perplexing because, by definition, they just aren't. It's a given that some chips will be soggy under the weight of the toppings, while others will wind up bare. But maybe, like the Brockabrella, it will prove that convention needs to be turned on its head every now and then.

Or maybe not: Though given more than the stated eight (closer to a dozen), the chips had an oddly uniform look to them. "There's no orphan in that bunch," a friend observed, and he was right. Each chip was blanketed with a white Monterey Jack cheese, but the onions, tomatoes and jalapeños were used only sparingly. Overall the dish was a whiff. The tangy chipotle sour cream proved indispensable, providing the only pop of flavor to an otherwise bland app.

The Verdict

Though Albert and Ozzie are generally known as solid guys on and off the field, the nachos at Pujols 5 were the ones that really, er, stepped up to the plate.

Support Local Journalism.
Join the Riverfront Times Press Club

Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state. Our readers helped us continue this coverage in 2020, and we are so grateful for the support.

Help us keep this coverage going in 2021. Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing membership pledge, your support goes to local-based reporting from our small but mighty team.

Join the Riverfront Times Club for as little as $5 a month.