Drink of the Week: Pastis Plenty, 33 Wine Shop & Tasting Bar


Supposedly the world is running out of bitters. Not bitter people, mind you, but the cocktail mixer. Specifically, Angostura bitters, those that come in the ubiquitous paper-wrapped bottle with the yellow plastic cap. Just a few years ago, such news wouldn't have attracted much notice. After all, cocktails rarely call for more than a few dashes of bitters, so a bottle would last most bars quite a while. But now that classic cocktails are all the rage, bar patrons are partying like it's 1929, knocking back Manhattans and Old-Fashioneds and running down those bitters supplies.

Nate Selsor of Monarch and TJ Vytlacil of Flamingo Bowl at the "Blood & Sand" Event - STEW SMITH
  • Stew Smith
  • Nate Selsor of Monarch and TJ Vytlacil of Flamingo Bowl at the "Blood & Sand" Event
At the "Blood & Sand" event at 33 Wine Shop & Tasting Bar on Monday night, Angostura bitters were not used in any of the night's eight featured cocktails, although four other kinds were. The event was sponsored by Pernod-Ricard, and as such, each cocktail showcased at least one of their brands. The drinks were $8 per, with proceeds going to promote the new St. Louis chapter of the United States Bartenders' Guild. Kind of like a really classy bake sale, with each of the participants (including Ted Kilgore of Taste by Niche) mixing up a different signature cocktail for the crowd.

My companion and I dutifully sampled them all. Although each was tasty, for me the standout was the Pastis Plenty mixed by Michelle Bildner of Monarch. Several of the evening's drinks featured absinthe, Pernod-Ricard's namesake spirit, but none so prominently as this one. Absinthe has a dangerous reputation, earned through the bad behavior of its enthusiasts, as demonstrated by Ernest Hemingway: "Got tight last night on absinthe and did knife tricks. Great success shooting the knife into the piano." (Some have surmised that it was absinthe that caused Vincent van Gogh to do knife tricks as well.) In modern times, the chief danger in mixing absinthe into your cocktails is in overwhelming the drink with its powerful anise flavor.

Indeed, the first sip of Pastis Plenty was like biting down on a black jelly bean. As that first impression faded, the cocktail distinguished itself from more commonplace mixed drinks. Apricot and maraschino liqueurs layered flavor and added complexity, lemon juice and Peychaud's bitters struck sour and bitter notes that balanced out the sweetness, and the presence of egg white gave the whole thing a pleasing viscosity and a frothy cap. This drink was served in a coupe glass -- the saucer-shaped, stemmed glass that champagne was once served in.

Each drink came in a different glass, some up, some on ice, always beautifully presented. The garnishes went beyond decoration, as in Chad George's take on a margarita with a rim of smoked sea salt and a flamed orange twist dropped in. The striking smoky scent and flavor lent a whole new dimension to an otherwise familiar drink.

  • Stew Smith
This kind of ingenuity and attention to detail was what the night was all about. In this column in May 2005, Randall Roberts wrote about a New York speakeasy that was pioneering the classic cocktail trend:
That Milk and Honey, a quiet bar that holds perhaps 40 patrons and has strict rules of behavior, can exist in high-rent New York is a shocker. Think what a good bartender with brains and passion could do in St. Louis, where the low cost of operation seems tailor-made for such an idea. Who's brave enough to attempt it? Who cares so much about cocktails that he or she will forgo the buzz for the sake of atmosphere?
The question is only louder now, as it has become clear that lack of talent is not the problem. But that talent has yet to find a home. Most of these skilled bartenders ply their trade in high-end restaurants, not bars. Even this fund-raiser was wedged into the small (charming, but small) confines of a wine bar on the night it's normally closed. My companion and I spent a good part of our evening awkwardly standing between tables, waiting for a seat to open up.

The problem that Roberts didn't foresee is that the cocktails have become the buzz. What's in danger of getting lost in the trappings of speakeasy culture -- the vests and ties, the lack of signage, etc. -- was once the point. More than four years later, we're still waiting for a place where drinker and bartender can interact beyond a shouted order, a low-key place where one can focus on a thoughtfully crafted cocktail and thoughtful conversation.

Alicia Lohmar is a south-city dweller and accomplished drinker, to which she credits her German ancestry and Catholic upbringing.


Support Local Journalism.
Join the Riverfront Times Press Club

Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state. Our readers helped us continue this coverage in 2020, and we are so grateful for the support.

Help us keep this coverage going in 2021. Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing membership pledge, your support goes to local-based reporting from our small but mighty team.

Join the Riverfront Times Club for as little as $5 a month.