I visit many restaurants -- too many to cover in the print version of the RFT. From time to time I'll share my thoughts on these visits in briefer and somewhat less formal blog-exclusive reviews.
The Mexican government recently hosted 50 American restaurateurs for lessons on what is and isn't true Mexican cuisine. I hope Canyon Café (1707 South Lindbergh Boulevard; 314-872-3443) scored an invite because over three recent visits to this Plaza Frontenac fixture, I tried an array of dishes that cited Mexican influence but didn't taste Mexican or even "Mexican." Except for a side dish of rice so heavily seasoned with cumin that I thought I'd clamped my mouth over someone's sweaty armpit, I didn't taste much of anything at all.
From the "Mex-Mex" menu (a warning sign right there), I had chicken enchiladas smothered in a blanket of bland three-pepper cream sauce -- I could see flecks of those three peppers, but they added little to the sauce -- and chicken enchiladas in a tomatillo-green chile sauce that had some tomatillo tartness but no peppery punch. A quesadilla with "fire-grilled" steak (another warning sign), blue cheese, red onion and Monterey jack (warning sign #3) was satisfying in a bland Applebee's appetizer kind of way, but the accompanying sauces were toothless: the avocado-tomatillo too light on the tomatillo, the chipotle mayonnaise too heavy on the mayo.
The quesadilla came from the "Tacos & Quesdillas" menu, whose mish-mash of Mex-Mex, Tex-Mex, Southwestern and more generic American influences could stand in for the lack of focus that plagues Canyon Café as a whole. There are "blackened" fish tacos in hard tortilla shells and soft tacos with lightly battered "Baja" shrimp. The quesadilla I had came with a salad that, although identified on the menu as "margarita slaw," tasted strongly and jarringly like sesame oil.
Not that I object on principle to playing around with different cuisines -- certainly not when they are already as interrelated as the cuisines of Mexico, Texas, the Southwest and California. And while I suppose my expectations should be low to begin with since Canyon Café is a chain, it's a small chain (just five locations according to its Web site) that allows each restaurant's executive chef some latitude with the menu.
Still, I had nothing that rose above ordinary. On my final visit I selected the carne asada from the "Signature Entrées" menu, which the Web site describes as both "Canyon-Mex" and "Chef-Mex." This was your basic backyard-grill steak -- tasty, if not especially distinctive -- topped with Monterey jack, mushroom, onion and bell pepper. It's basically one of those "smothered" dishes once featured at the T.J. O'Pootertoot's of the world, a concept nearly as dated as the soft rock playing on Canyon Café's sound system.
The Mexican government should forget the history lessons and just call in the troops.
Support Local Journalism.
Join the Riverfront Times Press Club
Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state. Our readers helped us continue this coverage in 2020, and we are so grateful for the support.
Help us keep this coverage going in 2021. Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing membership pledge, your support goes to local-based reporting from our small but mighty team.
Join the Riverfront Times Club for as little as $5 a month.